ashes 2009

Midwinter-Midwinter 2009 final points tally

As announced on Twitter last Monday morning following the conclusion of the Fifth Test, Graeme Swann made a late run to win the 2009 Midwinter-Midwinter by one point.

On day four at The Oval, Swann earned 3 points following his 2 and 1 on the two previous days to finish the series with a total of nine points. Mike Hussey scored two points on Sunday for his backs-to-the-wall hundred, with one point to Steve Harmison.

The Midwinter-Midwinter is the best on ground (BoG) award for the best player for both sides across the whole Ashes Test series. It is determined by me on the basis of deciding the three best players each day on a 3-2-1 basis. If a day is shortened for any reason (eg bad weather, end of game), then less votes will be allocated, either 2-1 or 1 only, depending on the number of overs bowled and the state of play. The prize for winning the Midwinter-Midwinter is the honour of being named the winner of the Midwinter-Midwinter. There is no actual trophy or medal.

Past winners: 2005 - Shane Warne; 2006-07 - Shane Warne.

The final tally:

9 - Graeme Swann (England);
8 - Stuart Broad, Paul Collingwood (England), Michael Clarke (Australia);
7 - Andrew Strauss (England);
6 - James Anderson, Andrew Flintoff (England), Ben Hilfenhaus, Marcus North, Peter Siddle (Australia);
4 - Brad Haddin, Simon Katich, Ricky Ponting (Australia);
3 - Matthew Prior, Jonathan Trott (England), Nathan Hauritz, Michael Hussey (Australia);
2 - Ian Bell, Alistair Cook, Graham Onions (England), Stuart Clark (Australia);
1 - Steve Harmison, Kevin Pietersen (England), Mitchell Johnson, Shane Watson (Australia).
0 - Ravi Bopara, Monty Panesar (England), Phil Hughes, Graham Manou (Australia).

Why Ponting should step down as Australian captain

If Cricket Australia was a failed Wall Street investment bank, then Ricky Ponting, Andrew Hilditch et al would probably be receiving huge bonuses right now. You know, the kind of performance-based bonuses that are paid out regardless of performance.

The selectors (are they still being called the NSP?) are spruiking the success of the Ashes series, which finished up Australia 1 England 2. Perhaps it would have been best for the NSPistas to exercise the right to remain silent. Andrew Hilditch: "As far as the selection processes are concerned, we had a really good Ashes, generally speaking". Jamie Cox, accepting that Nathan Hauritz should have played at The Oval: "Our Ashes, up until that one very well-defined moment, went very well for us."

I've seen no comment from Merv and Boonie. Let it stay that way. Their heads might be safer than those of the Test-Captain-who-never-was, AMJ Hilditch, and the Test-Opener-that-never-was, J Cox.

Ricky Ponting and Clive Lloyd are the only two captains to win two ICC World Cups. That's an enormous achievement to take into the annals of history. And, for the fifty-overs game, that's well and good. His performance at the Test game, however, is such that the time to resign or be resigned has arrived. For Ricky Ponting and Bill Murdoch are the only two Australian Test captains since 1890 to have lost the Ashes in England twice.

Ponting, as Australian captain, has presided over a drop from first place on the ICC rankings to fourth. The decline, and Ponting's captaincy, began well before the retirements of Hayden, Langer, Warne, McGrath and Gilchrist.

As well as being a double loser of the Ashes, Ponting lost a home series to South Africa last summer, and lost a series in India in 2008 after Australia had completed an unprecedented series win on India in 2004 (when Adam Gilchrist was captain while Ponting was injured).

Quite simply, Performance dictates dismissal. Ponting's performance as Test captain in recent years dictates that. The only real argument against Ponting's removal as captain would be the TINA factor - There Is No Alternative. However, there is an alternative, an able, intelligent, mature one by the name of Michael Clarke.

Ponting ranks alongside Greg Chappell as the best Australian batsmen in my lifetime. As long as he remains fit, there is no reason why Ponting cannot return to England for the 2013 Ashes and rack up fourteen or fifteen thousand runs in his Test career. But not as captain.

What the English papers said Monday morning

Click on the thumbnail to view a larger version.

What the English papers said Monday morning

Aussie cricket goes pear shaped at The Oval

It's done. The 2009 Ashes series couldn't have swung around more if half its surface was plastered with vaseline. England are the winners, deservedly so, congratulations to them, and as a matter of disclosure I bet one euro before the series began on an England 2-1 victory at 9.00. More bloggage later today.

Oval days one, two, three: Australian Blowout

"They've got a debutant playing this week, which I think will play in our favour a bit. What does it say to us? It probably shows a bit of desperation I guess on their behalf, to be doing that."

- Ricky Ponting on Jonathan Trott, 19.8.09 (source: ABC)

Despite all the "Australia on top" rhetoric on Thursday night, the first day of the Fifth Test at The Oval was about as close to a statistical "honours even" as you can get.

Then came the seismic shift on Friday afternoon. Australia's batting turned to mush. Stuart Broad was looking more like the new Sir Ian Botham or new Andrew Flintoff MBE. (The 2nd Lord Broad of Notts, perhaps?) It was enough to make one forget about that groundbreaking moment from Friday morning - Jimmy Anders0n's maiden Test duck.

But to bring us up to date, Australia is 80 for 0 in their second innings, needing a total of 546 to win the game with two days remaining.

The Ashes are as good as England's. But if it's an omen, it wasn't the fat lady preparing to sing in the Test Match Special booth yesterday, rather an appearance by Lily Allen.

466 runs in a maximum of about 180 overs, ten wickets in hand to save the Ashes for Australia. It's just tantalisingly plausible... isn't it?

Jonathan Trott's Test debut hundred is the standout highlight of the match thus far, and is an event destined for cricketing folklore as long as England goes on to win today or tomorrow. There was something perversely fitting about Andrew Flintoff's last Test innings ending with a six-and-out swipe.

Ricky Ponting is about to enter the history books as the first Australian captain to twice lose the Ashes since the 19th century (Billy Murdoch to be precise). His smug pre-match sledging of Trott is worthy of epitaph status. In future, Ricky, take the less-is-more approach to press conferences so ably demonstrated this week by Darius Boyd. Or better still, leave the statements to your future captain, Michael Clarke.

Points so far in The Oval Tine, er, Test for the 2009 Midwinter-Midwinter:
Day One - Siddle 3, Bell 2, Strauss 1;
Day Two - Broad 3, Swann 2, Katich 1;
Day Three - Trott 3, Strauss 2, Swann 1.

Leeds Day Three: It's Deja Vu Till The Fat Lady Sings

Wasn't it kind of the England team to forfeit the Fourth Test at the fall of the sixth wicket on Sunday and play a Twenty20 game instead. Nice, too, for the Australian bowlers to join in the fun.

It's not uncommon to have a late-order batting spree against the run of play when all is lost. The pressure has dropped away for both sides and the unorthodox takes over. That was definitely the case with Broad, Swann, Prior and Harmison at the end of the Headingley Test on Sunday. The madness of the moment shouldn't be used to denigrate Stuart Clark's vital first innings contribution to the winning of the Test for Australia.

Test cricket history is full of stories of late-order batting madness once a game is otherwise done and dusted. There has never been a case more insane than Nathan Astle's 222 as New Zealand went down to England at Christchurch in 2002.

But of course the most extraordinary batting explosion of all time in a losing cause was that by Sir Ian Botham and Graham Dilley in 1981. So much so that England went on to win.

Two last reflections from me on the final day of Australia's innings and 80 victory in the Fourth Test. One is that the symmetry between the fortunes of Stuart Clark and Mitchell Johnson is a sign that Australian cricket is in good shape. Of course, if they both fired at the same time it would be even better. The other is that Brad Haddin reminded us that he does not always play like a glorified backstop who can slog the ball when he bats.

Where does that leave the likely conclusion of the series? Just like 2005. Billy Bowden ceremonially removing the bails at The Oval to proclaim a draw. Different winner of the Ashes this time though.

'Tis deja vu till the fat lady sings.

Some views on the Fourth Test: Gideon Haigh (Business Spectator), Michael Henderson (The Telegraph UK), verse from Nick Whittock, undossiered bloggage from Justin Langer (cricket.com.au), and the following conspiracy theory:

"I still think the last test was a plot and Ahmadadinejad took the new ball, not Onions"

- Jonathan Agnew, Twitter, 10.8.09

T4D3 points for the Midwinter-Midwinter (and wouldn't a re-enactment of the great 1878 poaching scandal be a great idea before the start of play at The Oval?): Stuart Broad 2, Graeme Swann 1 in one-and-a-half sessions of play.

Michael Clarke and Paul Collingwood (8) share the lead going into the final Test, followed by Anderson, Flintoff, Hilfenhaus and North all on 6; Haddin, Ponting, Strauss on 4; Broad, Hauritz, Katich, Prior, Siddle on 3; Clark, Cook, Onions, Swann (sounds like a law firm at a gamefowl BBQ) on 2; Hussey, Johnson, Pietersen, Watson on 1. Nil pointes to Hughes, Manou, Bopara and Panesar.

Leeds Day Two: Call the Boparamedics!

Ravi Bopara has been an absolute batting genius for England against the West Indies. Three Test innings for three hundreds (104, 143, 108). Now take those three innings out of his career record, and what are left with?

Against Sri Lanka in 2007: 8, 34, 0, 0, 0.
Against Australia in 2009 to date: 35, 1, 18, 27, 23, 1, 0.
That's 147 runs at 12.15. And three of those four quackers were solid gold, including Saturday afternoon's demise.

Those numbers may have as much to say about the state of West Indian cricket as they do about Bopara's inappropriateness for the England number three position. Bopara hasn't played a single game for Essex this season. Make a date for the Championship Division Two game at home against Surrey starting August 19. He surely won't be playing at Surrey's home ground that weekend in the Fifth Test.

There's a chap by the name of Jonathan Trott who was named in the England squad this week, then sent back to Warwickshire where scored 78, well below his season's average to date of 91.00. And who's this 39 year-old lad from Surrey who's on the brink of his 108th first-class hundred this morning?

The apparent revelation that a member of Australian yobbistas "The Fanatics" set off the fire alarm at the England team hotel at 4am on Friday morning is simply dumbfounding. While it would be churlish to blame England's first innings performance on interrupted sleep, this was a very, very unfunny thing for any so-called cricket fan to be doing. Especially after the violent attack on the Sri Lankan Test team at Lahore in March. Whoever was responsible should be turned over to the Yorkshire Police and transported to Australia to perform compulsory armed service such as targeted air strikes on feral camels.

Having written next to nothing about another amazing day's play at Headingley, I give you the day's Midwinter-Midwinter votes: Marcus North 3 pts, Michael Clarke 2, Mitchell Johnson 1. Clarke now joins Paul Collingwood as joint leader on 8 pts with a truckload of players on 6.

Leeds Day One: Normal transmission has been resumed.

England wins the toss. England bats first. England is all out for 102 in the 34th over. Australia wins by nine wickets with 27 overs to sp.... oh hang on, it's a Test.

Maybe we can call a compromise and get the Fourth Test over with inside two days, just like England and the West Indies did at the same ground nine years ago. Yes it's the traditional Australia versus England mismatch we know and love so well.

For now. Saturday, as Scarlett O'Hara would have said if she was a Sky Sports cricket analyst, is another day.

But if there was any measure in the gulf between the two teams on Friday, it could be summed up with the following rhetorical question: Whose omission from the first three Tests was more lamentable - Steve Harmison's or Stuart Clark's?

There's one question for which I can't supply an answer: What sort of warmups do umpires perform before the start of a game? Point in discussion, the very first ball of the Test.

Andrew Strauss, just twenty minutes on from winning the toss and choosing to bat first, faces the Terry Alderman of 2009, Ben Hilfenhaus. A huge banana-bending inswinger from Hilfy appears destined for fine leg, then nips straight and hits Strauss' pads plumb in front. The skipper clips his boot with his bat but otherwise makes no contact. Billy Bowden, in for his first match of the series, gives it not out.

Players do their warm-ups right up till the last minute (though in the case of Matthew Prior and Brad Haddin that's not always advisable). What do umpires do so that they are in a state of peak physical and mental alertness from the very start of play?

Competition for the rickeyre.com Ashes Best-on-Ground award for the 2009 series is hotting up. The Midwinter-Midwinter is named in honour of an Australian player from the early days of the Ashes and an England player from the early days of the Ashes - who happen to be the same person, but whose cricketing nationality was transformed in one of the most infamous poaching incidents in sporting history. Several strong individual efforts in an eventful Friday, but my Midwinter-Midwinter points for Headingley Day One are: Peter Siddle 3, Stuart Clark 2, Ricky Ponting 1.

Brum Day Five: Never click the back button when you don't mean it

Captain-in-waiting Michael Clarke and Mister-Cricket-in-waiting Marcus North saved Australia's bacon in the Third Test at Edgbaston yesterday. With, it should be noted, the assistance of Mr Cricket himself, county-cricketer-in-waiting Mike Hussey, and chronic injury-in-waiting Shane Watson.

[What should have followed was a lengthy but probably dull discourse on the prospects of both teams for the remaining two Tests of the series. It vanished, unsaved, when I accidentally hit the "back" button on the wrong tab of my Firefox window. Suffice to say that I doubt England's ability to take twenty wickets in either of the Headingley or The Oval Tests, and that Australia can only do it if they recall Stuart Clark. Thus I'm now predicting that the England players will be heading back to the Palace next spring for an upgrade on their 2005 MBE's.]

Midwinter-Midwinter points for Day Five at Edgbaston: Michael Clarke 3, Marcus North 2, Mike Hussey 1. CIW Clarke has taken an outright lead on nine points, one ahead of Paul Collingwood MBE. I'll do an updated summary of the Midwinter-Midwinter before the start of Test Four.

Brum Days 2, 3, 4 Mid Term Report

Think of Saturday's day of inaction at Edgbaston not so much as a washout as a pause for half-time at the two-and-a-half Test point of the 2009 Ashes. It hasn't been a series of great science, but it's not dull. And we still don't really know how it's going to finish up.

These definitely are not two of the great Ashes teams, certainly neither is a patch on the 2005 lineups. Only Flintoff and Pietersen could be considered historically great England players. KP had an erratic start to the series before succumbing to injury. FF is still rocking on what ostensibly is his valedictory Test tour, but word is that he could fall to pieces at any minute. England will miss him. On the Douglas Jardine captaincy scale out of 10, Strauss would barely muster a 1.

Ricky Ponting continues to be an enigma as Australian captain. Two World Cups, and an 06-07 Ashes whitewash to his name, yet he is widely acknowledged as the worst Australian captain since Kim Hughes. Is this his final tour of England? It is easy to imagine that he will be back in 2013 at the age of 38, but I really do hope that he won't be captain by then - or anytime after this September.

Another Australian whose use-by date has come is chairman of selectors Andrew Hilditch, who has presided over some ghastly decisions, including the lack of a third opener on the current tour. The hasty chopping and changing of spinners in the past twelve months is likely to stand as Hilditch's worst legacy. (Have we forgotten Beau Casson, Cameron White, Bryce McGain and Jason Krejza already?)

Shane Watson seems to be kaput as a bowler, but can we take him seriously as a specialist opening batsman, ahead of Phil Hughes? I'll repeat what I said on Friday - regardless of how many runs Watson has scored, I am not convinced that Hughes couldn't have done better. We'll see what transpires in T4 if Mr Cricket fails today.

Perhaps the most pleasing observation of the Third Test to date has been the wicketkeeping of Graham Manou. Heaven forbid, a wicketkeeper chosen, not as a big-hitting batsman who can play backstop, but as a genuine custodian who can bat a bit. What does this do to the balance of the Australian team if Haddin is indeed out for the remainder of the series? At least we can't use the mantra "If it ain't broke, don't fix it", especially if Australia is two-down by Monday night...

Midwinter-Midwinter points for Day Two (Friday): Jimmy Anderson 3, Graham Onions 2, Andrew Strauss 1. Day Three (Saturday): No play. Day Four (Sunday): Andrew Flintoff 3, Ben Hilfenhaus 2, Stuart Broad 1. Collingwood still in front with 8, four players (Clarke, Hilfenhaus, Anderson, Flintoff) on 6.

Syndicate content